It’s not often I actually start writing a review with the title, but that’s how it’s coming out.
Manufacturing Delusion by Buck Sexton. The title of the book, itself, is a take-off of Chomsky and Herman’s Manufacturing Consent, a somewhat-seminal leftist tome that tied the origin of pretty much everything bad in the world to Capitalism, and US Industry.
After I finished the book, I said I should give it a few days to let my thoughts coalesce. They have, and although I respect Buck quite a bit, my initially-positive response has soured.
Time to get into the meat-and-potatoes.
- Recap of his bonafides is pretty good, and I understand how he reached some of the conclusions he posits. I admit holding reflective-antipathy towards CIA assets. I don’t know that that instinct has ever mislead me. Moderate Governor Langley in Virginia shows that brilliantly with her performance. (Missive about the Blue-Again-As-Harry-Byrd-Intended General Assembly’s performance excised for brevity; ask me offline). His bits about things like the Japanese Sarin attack in the 90s is something I certainly remember, but didn’t really pay close attention to. It’s similar to the 1994 AMIA Bombing, where the attorney who was working on the case in 2015 suspiciously “died by suicide” (I really hate that modern rewording….). But the bigger takeaway from his list drove another point home — in many, many, many ways, the 1990s sucked. I spent last week in Biloxi, Mississippi. Yes, quite a few things were rebuilt following Katrina, but I do remember Biloxi in the 1990s, spending a continuous month there so I was there long enough to sit for my Drivers’ Exam. Back then, pretty much every strip mall throughout d’Iberville had a pawn shop catering to people who’d lost their shirts at the newly-parked casinos. Hmm…. Maybe I’ll pick up an acoustic guitar while I’m down so I can plunk around on my train ride home. Nope. They’re all gone. No pickin’ in the Amtrak roomette. I did pick up something cheap on Space Cowboy Jeff’s Prime Days sale. It should be here later this week. But the roads in and around Biloxi were awful back then. Any wind would bring down branches. Over near where my mom’s house is, I can remember how badly twice-daily tides would cover some of the corners. But all of that is fixed now. Everything works. There’s Intertubes actually faster than I have at home inside the Beltway. Despite several storms, the power stayed on. The oppressive heat of a Mississippi summer was well-contained by air conditioning inside wherever I was. (My cousin’s kid’s car excepted, I stayed cool..). As I was going through Buck’s book, however, I started going through memories of the 1990s. I mentioned the Sarin attack and AMIA already, but there were many others.
- Mogadishu
- Ruby Ridge.
- Rwanda
- Bosnia
- Oklahoma City
- Khobar Towers
- 96 Atlanta Olympics
- Sudan “Wag The Dog,”
- USS Cole
- And so many others…
During all of that, nothing new really was built, the Federal Debt continued to grow, and…. The 90s weren’t so great.
- The Stalin discussions are interesting. Does it say something that a Georgian could win full power in the Soviet system? (I’ve said previously that a lot of the Left’s problems with ACB are that she’s not an Ivy League product. Small private undergrad? Notre Dame Law? You know how I know she’s a racist….?)
- I expect Putin to really start in on rehabilitation of his mentor Yuri Andropov. (My own prediction listening to it, but I think you can find out a lot about Putin by looking at how Andropov behaved in Hungary and Czechoslovakia…)
- The distortion means that reality becomes what the state says it is. (COVID was of natural origin. Hunter Biden wasn’t corrupt.)
- Stalin still has 70% approval in Russia, which is disappointing. (But maybe unsurprising.)
- Putin is rehabilitating Stalin because nobody is around to remember. (I’m wondering how true this still is with Ukrainian drones hitting all over Russia over the past couple of days. In the US, the rehab efforts lately have been on Jimmy Carter, and against Reagan. Yes, Carter let people brew beer, and ended some of the stupid regulations that were in place. Volcker did a good job at the Federal Reserve. But you have to keep at the top of mind lowering the Georgia flag to protest prosecution of Lieutenant Calley, Operation Eagle Claw, and his later support of the terrorists who’d become the DSA.)
- I feel bad for him that he went to UMass Amherst. (I did search a bit, and my reflexive antipathy is traceable to The Shadow University, and what I was doing on campus around 2000. What’s happened on campuses nationwide is actually the sort of thing I was concerned about. I believe in values generally enshrined in constitutional protections. And, no, I don’t hold those views on account of my overwhelming privilege. I graduated from Mencville High School in Newport News, Virginia, and that was the third high school I attended. I worked through college, a small public university, though I probably could have foregone work if I’d been okay with the restrictions that came with that. I was on the air with CBS News on a phone coupler when the clocks rolled to 1/1/00 after helping prepare for the switchover.)
- The self-segregation exercise are appalling. (And I think the HR staff who sponsored those sorts of things should find other ways to earn a living. I never really know where to put myself in those exercises. I’m not nearly as white as Senator Warren. I actually am physically-disabled. My privilege was attending three separate high schools as my dad was on Active Duty in the Army.)
- Tying the land acknowledgements to Maoist roots is interesting. Er. Good. (Who the hell am I supposed to acknowledge? My heritage is so varied that it’s tough to pin down. And one of my ancestors, who was a Choctaw elder who’s buried in the Congressional Cemetery after dying in DC following being honored for his efforts against the English in the War of 1812.)
- Good recap of the George Floyd riots, and their effects on his section of NYC.
- Decent recap of DeBlasio. (I would offer that NYC had two competent mayors since Ed Koch, who was taken down by the people now running the DSA.)
- The weapon use of law is important, too. I KNOW whatever is wrong, but I’m doing what the law says. So I’m free of any culpability legally and morally.
- The bits about outlawing Kosher food preparation is incredible. We’ll force them to eat the way the law prescribes, or they can STARVE. (Interesting parallels can be drawn to some of the Green New Deal alchemy….)
- Evil can be, and often is, pretty banal.
- Race and Ethnic restrictions on the legal field. *cough*DEI*cough*. (This kind of gets a reinforcing smack both with some of the SCOTUS rulings last few months, and the “moderate” members of the Party of the Klan losing NYC primaries to radicals.
- Volksgerichtshof courts from Nazi Germany were an interesting bit. I’m reminded of some of the pushes for justice not delivered by the conventional US courts. (I tend to prefer justice systems based on English Common Law, but I can appreciate those based on Napoleonic Code. Few of the “justice” pushes recently are based in either, and are really the whim of the deciders. Whether that’s campus administrators, CHOP/CHAZ, people who called for the executions of George Zimmerman, Kyle Rittenhouse, or Derek Chauvin. Or Donald Trump.)
- Interesting framing of his childhood in nasty NYC to Giuliani.
- Brief reflections on Muller probe, and Alvin Bragg, but little discussion of just how wrong the “walls are closing in” crowd were.
- I think there’s a ton more to delve into about Jack Smith. Smith’s convictions of “Tollbooth Bob” McDonnell were unanimously overturned by SCOTUS; 8-0 after Scalia died. And this is the guy somebody in the Garland DOJ hired to get Trump? Really? (How has Smith not been disbarred for what he did with the Mar-a-lago raids over the classified documents? Who, exactly, hired him in the first place?)
- Interesting section about the use of fear to compel compliance. If you don’t wash your groceries….. “Doing the right thing” satisfies: Extinction Fears, Climate apocalyptic worries, the way-more-deadly-than Ebola Virus.
- Paul Ehrlich. I suppose I understand the inclusion with his recent death, but I would argue that there’s nothing at all useful from his writings. I guess that he’s a great example of spreading fear to force compliance.
- I think he makes a correct association of Malthus and Ehrlich. (How many other charlatans have so perilously-humanity? These are horrible people, and it bothers me that some are trying to rehabilitate their images.)
Conclusion: it’s not a bad piece of work, but I don’t think most things are as cut-and-dried as he presents them. I’m trying to be less frustrated by things than I have been lately; this book didn’t do a lot to ease my mind. Whatever I think about the purveyors is really unimportant, but I’m not going to think of them fondly. You’re terrible people, and I only will associate with you if there’s absolutely no alternative.
The next thing I’m plowing through is Enemy Feminisms by Sophie Lewis. I’m almost finished, but, much like Buck’s book, there’s things that are overcome-by-events. Hers has a less-recent publication date, but I’ve already noticed a few places where the usual narratives have been severely-disrupted by events in the second Trump term. I’m not sure I’ll write a review of that, but I’d be willing to discuss with someone else who’s consumed it.